Before we got to the Florida Keys, A was definitely most excited about the key lime pie extravaganza he was planning. Surprisingly, this excitement continued throughout the entire trip. Like a trooper (closet fatty) that he is, he managed to eat two different pieces of key lime pie a day, excluding the day we spent in Key West, where we he ate 3! 9. He ate 9 pieces of key lime pie. What an animal!
4 of the 8 pieces sampled
@ Mrs. Mac's - Biggest let down. This was our LAST piece and we thought it was going to the best...she did claim 'world's best.'
@ Mattheessen's in Key West
@ Key Lime Pie Factory
And the winner is:
MILE MARKER 88
It definitely had the best atmosphere... can you really beat key lime pie on a beautiful and barely occupied beach?!
A thrilled with his first piece of key lime pie, which turned out to also be the best!
Overall winner, factoring in atmosphere, weather, taste, garnishes, etc.
What to Avoid: Deep Fried Key Lime Pie & Key Lime Pie on a stick. Everything else is a go!